Sculpted black quilted designer handbag cake with lipstick and perfume details

Custom Cakes & Services

Custom Cake Creations

Every cake starts as a conversation

Custom cake creations are the heart of the shop. Nothing in our custom case is pulled from a freezer or finished by a factory — each cake is designed with you, baked to order, and decorated by hand in Eastport, New York.

Bring us a color swatch, a Pinterest board, a photo of your grandmother's cake, or nothing at all. We'll shape the design around your event, and your guest count.

How a custom cake comes together

The process is deliberately simple, because you have a party to plan.

  • Send an inquiry with your date, guest count, and any inspiration photos.
  • We reply with a design direction, serving size, and an estimate price.
  • A deposit holds your date on the calendar.
  • We bake and decorate the cake fresh for your event.
  • You pick it up at 495 Montauk Highway, Eastport, NY 11941, or we deliver if delivery has been arranged.

Flavors, fillings, and finishes

Cake Flavors: Golden Vanilla Bean, Almond, Lemon, Cookies & Creme, Confetti, Carrot Cardamom, Velvet, Dark Chocolate, Espresso.

Filling Flavors: Italian Meringue Buttercream, Chocolate Silk, Cookies & Creme, Cream Cheese, Lemon Cream, Lemon Curd, Caramel Cream, Peanut Butter Cream, Chocolate Mousse, Vanilla Mousse, Chocolate Pastry Cream, Vanilla Pastry Cream, Raspberry Preserves, Strawberry Preserves, Cannoli.

Finishes range from rustic buttercream with semi-naked sides to smooth or textured fondant, hand-piped details, sugar florals, and buttercream paints.

Lead times and pricing honesty

Two - three weeks' notice is comfortable for most custom cakes. Wedding Cakes and Sculpted Cakes both book three to six months ahead. We provide an estimate before you commit.

Frequently asked

Book a Cake Tasting

Wedding, Engagement & Formal Cakes Gallery

See the full wedding, engagement & formal cakes portfolio

Reviews

What East End families say

Read all reviews
“Our four-tier cake was the most talked-about thing at the reception. Jerri walked us through flavors at the tasting and matched the buttercream texture to my dress lace exactly.”
Danielle R. · Westhampton Beach, NY · Wedding cake
“We called ten days before our engagement party in a panic. They took the order, nailed the design from a single photo, and it was ready for pickup right on time.”
Michael and Sara P. · Quogue, NY · Engagement party cake
“This is our family's birthday bakery, full stop. Three generations of cakes from the same shop. The cake is worth the drive from anywhere on the East End.”
Kathleen M. · Center Moriches, NY · Birthday cake

Start an Order

Start your custom cake creations order

Tell us your date, your guest count, and what you have in mind. We'll reply with a design direction and an estimate price — no guesswork, no pressure.

Other services

Call the ShopCustom Cake Inquiry