Golden square tiers trimmed with hand crafted brocade.

Our Story

A recognized local name, now with a kitchen to match

For years, Jerri's was a Westhampton Beach institution. A landmark spot near Main Street, a case people planned their weekends around, and a wedding cake calendar that filled up before the summer rentals did. Couples came in for a tasting, then came back a decade later for their kids' communion cakes.

What that village location could never give us was room. Custom cake work needs space — for tiers to chill, for sugar flowers to dry, for four wedding cakes to be finished at once on a Friday in July without anyone's elbow in anyone's buttercream.

So we moved west, to 495 Montauk Highway in Eastport, and built the shop we always wanted: a proper custom cake studio in the back, and a retail bakery case out front for anyone who wanders in for cupcakes and coffee cake.

What didn't change

Custom cake creations, made to order for the East End of Long Island. We still bake to order. We still provide an estimate before you commit. We still refuse to keep cakes in a freezer waiting for someone to want them.

And we're still a small, locally owned shop. When you call, you talk to someone who will be holding a piping bag later that day.

Pickup or arranged delivery

Orders are pick up by default unless delivery arrangements have been made. Pick up at 495 Montauk Highway, Eastport, NY 11941, or contact us to discuss delivery.

Who we bake for

Eastport is home, but our customers come from across the East End of Long Island — Westhampton Beach, Southampton, Quogue, Hampton Bays, Riverhead, Manorville, the Moriches, Speonk, Remsenburg, Shirley, and Mastic.

Reviews

A local name since 2009

Read all reviews
“Our four-tier cake was the most talked-about thing at the reception. Jerri walked us through flavors at the tasting and matched the buttercream texture to my dress lace exactly.”
Danielle R. · Westhampton Beach, NY · Wedding cake
“We called ten days before our engagement party in a panic. They took the order, nailed the design from a single photo, and it was ready for pickup right on time.”
Michael and Sara P. · Quogue, NY · Engagement party cake
“This is our family's birthday bakery, full stop. Three generations of cakes from the same shop. The cake is worth the drive from anywhere on the East End.”
Kathleen M. · Center Moriches, NY · Birthday cake

Visit the Shop

495 Montauk Highway, Eastport

Walk in for the case, or pick up an order you placed online. We're on Montauk Highway in the heart of Eastport, with parking right out front.

Store hours
MondayClosed
Tuesday8:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Wednesday8:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Thursday8:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Friday8:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Saturday8:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Sunday8:00 AM – 4:00 PM

Start an Order

Let's design your cake

Tell us your date, your guest count, and what you have in mind. We'll reply with a design direction and an estimate price — no guesswork, no pressure.

Call the ShopCustom Cake Inquiry