Custom Cakes & Services

Everything we bake, and how to order it

Jerri's Cakery is a custom cake bakery first and a retail case second. Some orders start with a consultation and a tasting; others are a two-minute pickup order. Below is every service we offer, with the lead time and ordering path for each.

  • Sculpted black quilted designer handbag cake with lipstick and perfume details

    Custom Cake Creations

    Every cake starts as a conversation

    Custom cake creations are the heart of the shop. Nothing in our custom case is pulled from a freezer or finished by a factory — each cake is designed with you, baked to order, and decorated by hand in Eastport, New York.

  • Our house made marshmallow fondant with blossom textures and hand crafted flower details.

    Wedding Cakes

    The wedding cake experience

    Wedding cakes are their own discipline, and we treat them that way. A consultation and a private cake tasting come before any design work — because a wedding cake that photographs beautifully and tastes forgettable is a missed opportunity.

  • Bright buttercream tiers with hand piped coral and pink roses.

    Engagement & Bridal Shower Cakes

    For the celebrations before the wedding

    An engagement party cake on Long Island and a bridal shower cake in Southampton NY have a different job than a wedding cake: they are photographed up close, cut early, and expected to be charming rather than monumental.

  • Monster truck cake on a checkered flag base in red and yellow

    Birthday & Celebration Cakes

    The everyday cakes families come back for

    Birthday cakes in Center Moriches NY, first communions in East Moriches, graduations in Shirley, retirements in Manorville — these are the cakes that make a bakery part of a town. Many of our customers have been ordering the same birthday flavor since 2009.

  • Sculpted seafood bushel cake with fondant crabs and seasoning tin

    Event & Corporate Desserts

    Dessert tables and desserts by the tray

    Event desserts for East End Long Island gatherings and corporate event cakes for Suffolk County offices are built for volume without looking like catering. Small format, high finish, easy to serve standing up.

  • Cupcake Bouquet

    Cupcakes, Cookies & Confections

    The case you can walk in and buy from

    Not everything needs a consultation. Cupcakes for Hampton Bays NY beach days, custom cookies on Long Island for team gifts, a dozen macarons because it's Tuesday — this is the everyday side of the shop.

Before You Order

Lead times & pickup, stated plainly

Lead times

  • Wedding Cakes and Sculpted Cakes. Book 3–6 months ahead. Tastings are by appointment, Wednesday through Saturday.
  • Custom celebration cakes. Two - three weeks' notice.
  • Bake shop pickup orders. Place your order at least 48 hours before your pickup date.
  • Dessert tables & corporate orders. Three to four weeks for large-format displays and branded desserts.

How pickup works

  • Orders are pick up by default unless delivery arrangements have been made.
  • Pickup slots are confirmed by phone or email once we review your date.
  • A deposit holds your date for custom and wedding work; the balance is due at pickup.
  • Allergy and dietary requests are handled case by case — tell us in your inquiry.

Reviews

Reviews from the people we bake for

Read all reviews
“Our four-tier cake was the most talked-about thing at the reception. Jerri walked us through flavors at the tasting and matched the buttercream texture to my dress lace exactly.”
Danielle R. · Westhampton Beach, NY · Wedding cake
“We called ten days before our engagement party in a panic. They took the order, nailed the design from a single photo, and it was ready for pickup right on time.”
Michael and Sara P. · Quogue, NY · Engagement party cake
“This is our family's birthday bakery, full stop. Three generations of cakes from the same shop. The cake is worth the drive from anywhere on the East End.”
Kathleen M. · Center Moriches, NY · Birthday cake

Start an Order

Let's design your cake

Tell us your date, your guest count, and what you have in mind. We'll reply with a design direction and an estimate price — no guesswork, no pressure.

Call the ShopCustom Cake Inquiry