Monster truck cake on a checkered flag base in red and yellow

Service Area

Custom Cakes for Eastport, NY

Our hometown — you're already here

We are the bakery in Eastport NY, and this is home. Our storefront sits on the south side of Montauk Highway, two buildings west of the lake. We love our town and encourage you to stop in for coffee and a cupcake!

Ordering a cake for Eastport

  • We know the Eastport-South Manor school calendar better than we probably should — concert nights, graduation weekend, and the last day of school are our busiest cookie days of the year.
  • Duck farm history runs deep here, and so does the summer traffic on Montauk Highway. If you're picking up on a July Saturday, come before noon and you'll skip the crawl toward the Hamptons.
  • Local families use us as the standing dessert stop for backyard parties along Seatuck Creek and the Eastport waterfront.

Events and venues

  • Eastport-South Manor Junior-Senior High School events
  • Eastport Fire Department hall functions
  • Backyard and waterfront parties off Seatuck Creek

Cake services for Eastport

  • Custom Cake Creations

    Every cake starts as a conversation. Custom cakes in Eastport NY, designed and baked to order at our Montauk Highway storefront. Sketch-to-cake design, tastings, and pickup for the whole East End.

  • Birthday & Celebration Cakes

    The everyday cakes families come back for. Birthday cakes for Center Moriches NY, custom cakes for Manorville NY, and celebration cakes across the East End. Order Online at our Eastport bakery.

  • Cupcakes, Cookies & Confections

    The case you can walk in and buy from. Cupcakes for Hampton Bays NY, custom cookies on Long Island, and small-batch confections. Order Online at our Eastport NY bakery on Montauk Highway.

Reviews

East End reviews

Read all reviews
“Our four-tier cake was the most talked-about thing at the reception. Jerri walked us through flavors at the tasting and matched the buttercream texture to my dress lace exactly.”
Danielle R. · Westhampton Beach, NY · Wedding cake
“We called ten days before our engagement party in a panic. They took the order, nailed the design from a single photo, and it was ready for pickup right on time.”
Michael and Sara P. · Quogue, NY · Engagement party cake
“This is our family's birthday bakery, full stop. Three generations of cakes from the same shop. The cake is worth the drive from anywhere on the East End.”
Kathleen M. · Center Moriches, NY · Birthday cake

Visit the Shop

495 Montauk Highway, Eastport

Walk in for the case, or pick up an order you placed online. We're on Montauk Highway in the heart of Eastport, with parking right out front.

Store hours
MondayClosed
Tuesday8:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Wednesday8:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Thursday8:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Friday8:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Saturday8:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Sunday8:00 AM – 4:00 PM

Start an Order

Start your Eastport cake order

Tell us your date, your guest count, and what you have in mind. We'll reply with a design direction and an estimate price — no guesswork, no pressure.

Call the ShopCustom Cake Inquiry